Niagara on the Lake is one of those rare places where history and luxury go hand in hand, creating an atmosphere that feels both timeless and indulgent. But what truly sets it apart for me? The vintage hotels—grand, elegant, and brimming with character that transported me to another era while still offering all the modern comforts I crave. Here are my favorite vintage hotels in Niagara on the Lake.
Pillar and Post
There’s something about Pillar and Post that draws me in every time. No matter the season, it always feels like the perfect place to escape and unwind.
History
Pillar and Post, built as a canning factory in 1890, played a significant role in Niagara’s agricultural industry. During World War I, it briefly housed Polish soldiers training in Canada. Evolved into an inn in the 1970s, Pillar and Post preserved its post and beam construction while expanding into the elegant retreat it is today.
Outdoor Grotto Hot Tub
I’ve spent countless hours soaking in the Outdoor Grotto Hot Tub, letting the warm, mineral-rich water melt away any tension. The combination of soothing heat and the surrounding ambiance makes it an unbeatable retreat.
Pro tip: Make your reservations early, this popular spot fills up quickly!
Heated Outdoor Pool
Even in winter, I’ve braved the heated outdoor pool—it’s refreshing, though it doesn’t quite rival the cozy embrace of the grotto.
The Cannery Restaurant
The Cannery Restaurant is a great spot to dine. Featuring both a dinner menu and a breakfast buffet, it’s both casual and upscale at the same time. Offering an old-world vibe and locally inspired dishes that perfectly complement the region’s wines, it’s always a great spot to dine. We thoroughly enjoyed both our dinner and breakfast brunch at The Cannery.
Fireside Lounge
The Fireside Lounge is my favorite spot at Post & Pillar. It is small and cozy, and fills up quickly. Get there early, score a spot by the fireplace and unwind with a glass of wine before dinner.
Pro tip: They also serve light bites here, making it a great spot for a light dinner.
Skating Rink & Gardens
On cold winter evenings, I lace up my skates and glide across the rink just across the road, feeling the crisp chill on my face. Gardens are covered in snow, so walking the snow-covered paths and warming up by the fire pits is a better choice.
Pro tip: Ask for hours of operation at the front desk. It’s not open all the time.
Prince of Wales Hotel
Walking into the Prince of Wales Hotel feels like stepping into a different era. The attention to detail, from the ornate décor to the elegant service, makes every stay feel truly special.
History
Established in 1864, this Victorian landmark has been part of the town’s fabric for over a century. It has maintained its grandeur through careful preservation. It was built initially to welcome travelers arriving by carriage. The rich history of this hotel can be felt in every antique-filled corridor and timelessly elegant suite.
Heated Indoor Pool
The pool’s elegant design, with its soft lighting and tasteful décor, instantly creates an inviting atmosphere that helps me relax and truly unwind. I often enjoy a refreshing morning swim or a soothing evening dip after exploring Niagara on the Lake; in both moments, this warm aquatic retreat feels like my personal oasis. And knowing it’s open to both hotel guests and day spa visitors makes it a cherished spot all year round.
Secret Garden Spa
When I entered the Secret Garden Spa, I was greeted by calming scents and a welcoming atmosphere that immediately put me at ease. A massage here is the perfect way to recharge after a day of exploring Niagara on the Lake, with its spa’s serene treatment rooms and calming atmosphere, making it a perfect break from the bustle of daily life.
English High Tea
A classic tradition served daily, English High Tea at the Prince of Wales Hotel is an experience I never miss. The delicate pastries, the finely brewed tea, and the elegant china transport are over the top and just about perfect.
Pro tip: book your high tea experience early as they book up fast, and ask for a table by the window for the best people watching.
Victorian Drawing Room
The rich wood paneling, plush chairs, and warm lighting are perfect for relaxing and enjoying a drink, evoking the classic Victorian lounge experience. It’s a place that invites you to linger and enjoy the moment, and I always find myself drawn to this space.
Queen’s Landing
Queen’s Landing instantly captivates with its stately elegance and picturesque setting along the Niagara River. Every time I step inside, I feel like I’ve entered a grand estate where past and present blend seamlessly.
History
Queen’s Landing, which was built in 1990 on a property dating back to the 1830s, reflects Georgian-era grandeur. Inspired by neoclassical design, the hotel’s architecture pays homage to its historical roots while offering modern luxury. Walking through its grand corridors, you can almost imagine the elegant gatherings that once took place on this very land.
Tiara Restaurant
Tiara Restaurant offers panoramic views of the Niagara River with a fine dining focus on local, seasonal ingredients. I had a wonderful experience trying Foie Gras Torchon—a delight featuring the combination of creamy foie gras with peach preserves, maple sea salt, and crisp brioche.
Grand Staircase
A stunning feature adding to the hotel’s opulence. It’s a cinematic staircase that is like stepping into a period drama, where every detail is designed to impress.
Moffat Inn
Moffat Inn has a way of making me feel right at home. Maybe it’s the charming decor or the friendly, welcoming atmosphere that wraps around you the moment you arrive.
History
Once part of the Moffat family’s 19th-century estate, this inn has maintained its cozy charm while embracing modern comforts. Originally a private residence, it later evolved into a welcoming haven for travelers looking for a restful escape.
Fresh Floral Decor
The inn is known for its fresh floral arrangements, which bring a lively and homey touch to every corner. There’s something special about walking into a room filled with the scent of fresh flowers—it instantly lifts my mood.
Country-Style Patio
One of my favorite ways to start the day is sitting on the charming country-style patio with a warm cup of coffee. The relaxed setting, surrounded by lush greenery, makes for the perfect spot to soak in the fresh air and slow down for a moment.
Garden Retreat
Just steps away from the town’s hustle and bustle, the inn’s garden offers a soothing escape. I love taking a quiet moment here, letting the peaceful ambiance wash over me before heading out to explore Niagara on the Lake.
The Charles Hotel
The Charles Hotel has an old-world charm that is always captivating. There is always that feeling of stepping into a refined past while indulging in modern comfort.
History
Built in 1832 by politician Charles Richardson as a summer residence, The Charles Hotel carries nearly two centuries of history within its walls. Originally a private estate, it has since been transformed into a boutique hotel while preserving its period details.
Antique Furnishings
Each room is uniquely decorated with antique furnishings that add character and warmth. I love running my fingers over the intricate woodwork, imagining the stories these pieces could tell.
Cozy Common Areas
The intimate sitting rooms are my go-to spots for curling up with a good book or enjoying quiet conversation. There’s something comforting about sinking into a well-loved chair and letting time slow down.
Historic Architecture
From hand-hewn beams to the thick plank floors laid in 1815, every architectural detail at The Charles Hotel speaks to its rich past. Walking through its halls, I can’t help but appreciate the craftsmanship that has stood the test of time.
History Meets Hospitality
Each vintage hotel tells a story, one that you don’t just read about—you feel it in the warm glow of a fireside lounge, in the delicate flavors of a carefully prepared meal, and in the timeless elegance of historic architecture. The creak of wooden floors, the flicker of candlelight, and the sense of history all add to the experience. If you’re craving an escape from the ordinary, these vintage hotels offer an unforgettable journey into the past.